Search Articles

Find the latest news and articles

NPS vs PPF Comparison of Returns, Tax Benefits and Withdrawal Rules

By Aditya Nagar | Updated: Tue, 17 Nov 2026, 10:41 AM (IST)
NPS vs PPF Comparison of Returns, Tax Benefits and Withdrawal Rules

PPF vs NPS: Investing is a great way to grow your savings over time. In India there are two popular government schemes that you can invest in: the NPS and the PPF. They serve two very different purposes. The NPS is a retirement scheme and the PPF is a long-term wealth creation scheme which also provides tax benefits. You can open and manage both of these schemes through ICICI Bank's digital services. In this post we look at both schemes, compare them and help you decide which one is right for you.

Knowing the Concept of NPS: Is it a Worth Investing in?

Is NPS a good investment? The answer is yes: it is a good, low-cost investment for those looking for long-term retirement planning. However, investors must also adhere to its unbending lock-in rules and annuity requirements.

NOTE: Get stock market news, startup trends, finance insights, business updates, and Latest updates.

Now let us understand the key concept of NPS or National Pension Scheme. If you're looking for a government backed way of saving for retirement then this plan can help you to build up your savings and provide you with a regular income in the future. It's available to anyone between the ages of 18 and 70.

You can join whether you're in India or overseas and it's a plan that's specifically designed to help you save for your retirement. There are two types of account available: Tier 1 and Tier 2.

With the Tier 1 account it's more difficult to access the funds prior to retirement which is obviously the ideal situation if you're trying to save. With the Tier 2 account you can access the funds more easily but of course it doesn't have the same tax advantages.

NPS Returns Comparison with Other Investment Options

PPF vs NPS Returns difference: To see whether NPS returns are better than PPF or other investment options, here is a table for a clear comparison.

NPSPPF
Market-dependentGovernment-backed)
Typically, 9-12%Up to 7.1% (fixed)
₹2 lakh deduction₹1.5 lakh deduction
Partial withdrawals allowed after ten yearsPartial withdrawals after seven years
Suggested for retirement savings regarding long-term planIdeal for investors who don’t want to take risks
NPSMutual Funds
Market-dependentModerate to high
Typically, 9-12%10-14%
₹2 lakh deductionNo direct deductions
Management fees are lessManagement fees are higher
Does not have much switching optionsMore than one option for funding
NPSFixed Deposits
Market-dependentLow 
Typically, 9-12% 6-7%
₹2 lakh deductionInterest Taxable 
Partial withdrawals allowed after 10 years Premature withdrawal penalties 
Long-term retirement savings short -to medium-term savings 

PPF or NPS: Which is better for Tax saving?

PPF vs NPS: Many people want to know the difference between PPF and NPS in terms of tax savings. The answer is that NPS and PPF are two popular schemes, mainly because of the tax benefits they offer. With an NPS Tier I account, you can claim tax deductions under Section 80C and Section 80CCD(1B) of the Income Tax Act, up to the prescribed limits. That's a big reason for the scheme's popularity, as it's a great way to save for retirement.

Both schemes have their own tax benefits. With NPS you get tax free withdrawals at maturity but the annuity income is taxable. With PPF it's all tax free. Your contributions, the interest and the withdrawals are all tax free. So, if your main objective is to reduce your tax liability then PPF is probably the better option.

PPF vs NPS for Retirement | Which Makes a Better Option?

PPF vs NPS: Planning for retirement is the key to financial security and to reducing the stress of ageing. In India the two most common forms of retirement savings are the National Pension Scheme (NPS) and the Public Provident Fund (PPF). Both are government backed, provide tax benefits and are intended to help you build a solid financial future.

The difference between the two is in the way they work, the returns they provide and the degree of flexibility they offer. The right choice can make a massive difference to your life in retirement.

PPF vs NPS Tax Benefits

Tax is a significant factor when comparing NPS and PPF. Previously you could claim a deduction for your PPF contributions under Section 80C of the Income-tax Act, 1961. With the Income-tax Act, 2025, the deduction is now primarily available through Section 1NPS (a bit more complicated).

You can claim your own NPS contribution under Section 80CCD (1) within the overall limit of the old regime and also claim an additional deduction of up to ₹50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B).

Under the 2025 Act, NPS deductions are covered under Section 124 for contributions to a pension scheme. Employer contributions (previously under Section 80CCD (2) and now under Section 124 of the Income Tax Act, 2025) are still beneficial in the new regime, though there are caps.

PPF vs NPS Withdrawal Rules: Must to Know

PPF vs NPS: To understand the withdrawal rules for PPF and NPS, we need to look at them separately.

NPS Withdrawal Rules

  • If your corpus is in excess of ₹12 lakh you can take out up to 80% as a lump sum.
  • Of that 80%, 60% is tax free under Section 10(12A) and the remaining 20% will be taxed as per your income slab until the Income Tax Act is amended.
  • The final 20% must be used to purchase an annuity. If your corpus is between ₹8 lakh and ₹12 lakh you can take out up to ₹6 lakh as a lump sum.
  • The remainder can be taken out via Systematic Unit Redemption (SUR) over a minimum of 6 years or used to purchase an annuity.
  • For a corpus of up to ₹8 lakh you can take out the entire amount as a lump sum and so there is no requirement to buy an annuity.
  • After 3 years from the date of opening of the account you can make partial withdrawals from Tier I up to 25% of your own contributions.
  • These are allowed for specific purposes such as your children's education, marriage, purchase of a house or for a critical illness.
  • You can do this up to 4 times during the course of your subscription but only once every 4 years.
  • The maximum deferral age has now been raised to 85 years as per the amendment made in December 2025.

PPF Withdrawal Rules

  • You can only take out the full amount after the 15-year lock-in period and that will be tax free.
  • From the 6th financial year, you can make one partial withdrawal each year.
  • The maximum you can take out is 50% of the balance at the end of the 4th year prior to the withdrawal or the balance at the end of the previous year, whichever is the lower of the two.
  • If you wish to close the account prior to the 5-year mark you can do so only if you, your spouse or your dependent children have a life-threatening illness or if you or your dependent children require funds for higher education.
  • In such circumstances you can close the account early but there will be a 1% reduction in the rate of interest as a penalty.
  • After 15 years you can extend the account in 5-year blocks. If you cease to make any further contributions you can take out any amount once a year with no limit.
  • If you continue to make contributions by submitting Form H within one year of maturity you can take out up to 60% of the balance at the time of extension over the 5-year block and one withdrawal per year.

Flypped Conclusion

When it comes to PPF vs NPS both are good options for retirement. Which is the right one for you is going to be down to your own personal circumstances, your financial objectives, your risk appetite and how long you intend to invest. If you're after higher returns, are prepared to take some market risk and also want the added benefit of tax savings then NPS may be the better option for you.

It's a good option for someone who wants to build up a big retirement corpus and is prepared to invest over the long term. NPS typically provides a good balance of growth and safety which can be used to generate a reliable income in retirement. Think about your own needs, get advice from a financial advisor and pick the one that's right for you.

Read More:

Frequently Asked Questions

Find answers to common questions about this topic

Can I invest in both PPF and NPS?

Yes, you can invest in both simultaneously and claim tax deductions under Sections 80C and 80CCD(1B).

Is NPS and PPF same?

No. PPF offers guaranteed, tax-free fixed returns over 15 years, while NPS provides market-linked retirement returns until age 60.

Can a person take NSC and PEP simultaneously?

Yes, assuming "PEP" means PPF or EPF, you can hold both alongside NSC within the ₹1.5 lakh 80C limit.

Is NPS Pension for lifetime?

Yes, at least 40% of your NPS retirement corpus buys an annuity providing a guaranteed monthly pension for life.

How can I get ₹20,000 pension per month in NPS?

Build a ₹1 crore NPS corpus (investing ₹4,400/month for 30 years) and allocate 40% to a 6% annuity plan.